This is an updated copy of the version on BadHistory. I plan to update it in accordance with the feedback I got. I'd like to thank two people who will remain anonymous for helping me greatly with this post (you know who you are) submitted by
Three years ago a festschrift
for Binay Bhushan Chaudhuri was published by Shubhra Chakrabarti, a history teacher at the University of Delhi and Utsa Patnaik, a Marxist economist who taught at JNU until 2010.
One of the essays in the festschirt by Utsa Patnaik was an attempt to quantify the "drain" undergone by India during British Rule. Her conclusion? Britain robbed India of $45 trillion (or £9.2 trillion) during their 200 or so years of rule. This figure was immensely popular, and got republished in several major news outlets (here
(they get the number wrong) and more recently here
), got a mention from the Minister of External Affairs
& returns 29,100 results on Google
. There's also plenty of references
to it here on Reddit.
Patnaik is not the first to calculate such a figure. Angus Maddison thought it was £100 million, Simon Digby said £1 billion, Javier Estaban said £40 million see Roy (2019)
. The huge range of figures should set off some alarm bells.
So how did Patnaik calculate this (shockingly large) figure? Well, even though I don't have access to the festschrift, she conveniently has written an article detailing her methodology here
. Let's have a look.
How exactly did the British manage to diddle us and drain our wealth’ ? was the question that Basudev Chatterjee (later editor of a volume in the Towards Freedom project) had posed to me 50 years ago when we were fellow-students abroad.
This is begging the question.
After decades of research I find that using India’s commodity export surplus as the measure and applying an interest rate of 5%, the total drain from 1765 to 1938, compounded up to 2016, comes to £9.2 trillion; since $4.86 exchanged for £1 those days, this sum equals about $45 trillion.
This is completely meaningless. To understand why it's meaningless consider India's annual coconut exports. These are almost certainly a surplus but the surplus in trade is countered by the other country buying the product
(indeed, by definition
, trade surpluses contribute to the GDP of a nation which hardly plays into intuitive conceptualisations of drain).
Furthermore, Dewey (2019)
critiques the 5% interest rate.
She [Patnaik] consistently adopts statistical assumptions (such as compound interest at a rate of 5% per annum over centuries) that exaggerate the magnitude of the drain
The exact mechanism of drain, or transfers from India to Britain was quite simple.
Drain theory possessed the political merit of being easily grasped by a nation of peasants. [...] No other idea could arouse people than the thought that they were being taxed so that others in far off lands might live in comfort. [...] It was, therefore, inevitable that the drain theory became the main staple of nationalist political agitation during the Gandhian era.
- Chandra et al. (1989)
The key factor was Britain’s control over our taxation revenues combined with control over India’s financial gold and forex earnings from its booming commodity export surplus with the world. Simply put, Britain used locally raised rupee tax revenues to pay for its net import of goods, a highly abnormal use of budgetary funds not seen in any sovereign country.
The issue with figures like these is they all make certain methodological assumptions that are impossible to prove. From Roy in Frankema et al. (2019)
the "drain theory" of Indian poverty cannot be tested with evidence, for several reasons. First, it rests on the counterfactual that any money saved on account of factor payments abroad would translate into domestic investment, which can never be proved. Second, it rests on "the primitive notion that all payments to foreigners are "drain"", that is, on the assumption that these payments did not contribute to domestic national income to the equivalent extent (Kumar 1985, 384; see also Chaudhuri 1968). Again, this cannot be tested. [...] Fourth, while British officers serving India did receive salaries that were many times that of the average income in India, a paper using cross-country data shows that colonies with better paid officers were governed better (Jones 2013).
Indeed, drain theory rests on some very weak foundations. This, in of itself, should be enough to dismiss any of the other figures that get thrown out. Nonetheless, I felt it would be a useful exercise to continue exploring Patnaik's take on drain theory.
The East India Company from 1765 onwards allocated every year up to one-third of Indian budgetary revenues net of collection costs, to buy a large volume of goods for direct import into Britain, far in excess of that country’s own needs.
So what's going on here? Well Roy (2019)
explains it better:
Colonial India ran an export surplus, which, together with foreign investment, was used to pay for services purchased from Britain. These payments included interest on public debt, salaries, and pensions paid to government offcers who had come from Britain, salaries of managers and engineers, guaranteed profts paid to railway companies, and repatriated business profts. How do we know that any of these payments involved paying too much? The answer is we do not.
So what was really happening is the government was paying its workers for services (as well as guaranteeing profits - to promote investment - something the GoI does today Dalal (2019)
, and promoting business in India), and those workers were remitting some of that money to Britain. This is hardly a drain (unless, of course, Indian diaspora around the world today are "draining" it). In some cases, the remittances would take the form of goods (as described) see Chaudhuri (1983)
It is obvious that these debit items were financed through the export surplus on merchandise account, and later, when railway construction started on a large scale in India, through capital import. Until 1833 the East India Company followed a cumbersome method in remitting the annual home charges. This was to purchase export commodities in India out of revenue, which were then shipped to London and the proceeds from their sale handed over to the home treasury.
While Roy's earlier point argues better paid officers governed better, it is honestly impossible to say what part of the repatriated export surplus was a drain, and what was not. However calling all of it a drain is definitely misguided.
It's worth noting that Patnaik seems to make no attempt to quantify the benefits of the Raj either, Dewey (2019)
's 2nd criticism:
she [Patnaik] consistently ignores research that would tend to cut the economic impact of the drain down to size, such as the work on the sources of investment during the industrial revolution (which shows that industrialisation was financed by the ploughed-back profits of industrialists) or the costs of empire school (which stresses the high price of imperial defence)
Since tropical goods were highly prized in other cold temperate countries which could never produce them, in effect these free goods represented international purchasing power for Britain which kept a part for its own use and re-exported the balance to other countries in Europe and North America against import of food grains, iron and other goods in which it was deficient.
Re-exports necessarily adds value to goods when the goods are processed and when the goods are transported. The country with the largest navy at the time would presumably be in very good stead to do the latter.
The British historians Phyllis Deane and WA Cole presented an incorrect estimate of Britain’s 18th-19th century trade volume, by leaving out re-exports completely. I found that by 1800 Britain’s total trade was 62% higher than their estimate, on applying the correct definition of trade including re-exports, that is used by the United Nations and by all other international organisations.
While interesting, and certainly expected for such an old book, re-exporting necessarily adds value to goods.
When the Crown took over from the Company, from 1861 a clever system was developed under which all of India’s financial gold and forex earnings from its fast-rising commodity export surplus with the world, was intercepted and appropriated by Britain. As before up to a third of India’s rising budgetary revenues was not spent domestically but was set aside as ‘expenditure abroad’.
So, what does this mean? Britain appropriated all of India's earnings, and then spent a third of it aboard? Not exactly. She is describing home charges see Roy (2019)
Some of the expenditures on defense and administration were made in sterling and went out of the country. This payment by the government was known as the Home Charges. For example, interest payment on loans raised to finance construction of railways and irrigation works, pensions paid to retired officers, and purchase of stores, were payments in sterling. [...] almost all money that the government paid abroad corresponded to the purchase of a service from abroad. [...] The balance of payments system that emerged after 1800 was based on standard business principles. India bought something and paid for it. State revenues were used to pay for wages of people hired abroad, pay for interest on loans raised abroad, and repatriation of profits on foreign investments coming into India. These were legitimate market transactions.
Indeed, if paying for what you buy is drain, then several billions of us are drained every day.
The Secretary of State for India in Council, based in London, invited foreign importers to deposit with him the payment (in gold, sterling and their own currencies) for their net imports from India, and these gold and forex payments disappeared into the yawning maw of the SoS’s account in the Bank of England.
It should be noted that India having two heads was beneficial, and encouraged investment per Roy (2019)
The fact that the India Office in London managed a part of the monetary system made India creditworthy, stabilized its currency, and encouraged foreign savers to put money into railways and private enterprise in India. Current research on the history of public debt shows that stable and large colonies found it easier to borrow abroad than independent economies because the investors trusted the guarantee of the colonist powers.
Against India’s net foreign earnings he issued bills, termed Council bills (CBs), to an equivalent rupee value. The rate (between gold-linked sterling and silver rupee) at which the bills were issued, was carefully adjusted to the last farthing, so that foreigners would never find it more profitable to ship financial gold as payment directly to Indians, compared to using the CB route. Foreign importers then sent the CBs by post or by telegraph to the export houses in India, that via the exchange banks were paid out of the budgeted provision of sums under ‘expenditure abroad’, and the exporters in turn paid the producers (peasants and artisans) from whom they sourced the goods. Sunderland (2013)
argues CBs had two main roles (and neither were part of a grand plot to keep gold out of India):
Council bills had two roles. They firstly promoted trade by handing the IO some control of the rate of exchange and allowing the exchange banks to remit funds to India and to hedge currency transaction risks. They also enabled the Indian government to transfer cash to England for the payment of its UK commitments.
The United Nations (1962) historical data for 1900 to 1960, show that for three decades up to 1928 (and very likely earlier too) India posted the second highest merchandise export surplus in the world, with USA in the first position. Not only were Indians deprived of every bit of the enormous international purchasing power they had earned over 175 years, even its rupee equivalent was not issued to them since not even the colonial government was credited with any part of India’s net gold and forex earnings against which it could issue rupees. The sleight-of-hand employed, namely ‘paying’ producers out of their own taxes, made India’s export surplus unrequited and constituted a tax-financed drain to the metropolis, as had been correctly pointed out by those highly insightful classical writers, Dadabhai Naoroji and RCDutt.
It doesn't appear that others appreciate their insight Roy (2019)
K. N. Chaudhuri rightly calls such practice ‘confused’ economics ‘coloured by political feelings’.
Surplus budgets to effect such heavy tax-financed transfers had a severe employment–reducing and income-deflating effect: mass consumption was squeezed in order to release export goods. Per capita annual foodgrains absorption in British India declined from 210 kg. during the period 1904-09, to 157 kg. during 1937-41, and to only 137 kg by 1946. Dewey (1978)
points out reliability issues with Indian agriculutural statistics, however this calorie decline persists to this day. Some of it is attributed to less food being consumed at home Smith (2015)
, a lower infectious disease burden Duh & Spears (2016)
and diversified diets Vankatesh et al. (2016)
If even a part of its enormous foreign earnings had been credited to it and not entirely siphoned off, India could have imported modern technology to build up an industrial structure as Japan was doing.
This is, unfortunately, impossible to prove. Had the British not arrived in India, there is no clear indication that India would've united (this is arguably more plausible than the given counterfactual1
). Had the British not arrived in India, there is no clear indication India would not have been nuked in WW2, much like Japan. Had the British not arrived in India, there is no clear indication India would not have been invaded by lizard people,
much like Japan.
The list continues eternally.
Nevertheless, I will charitably examine the given counterfactual anyway. Did pre-colonial India have industrial potential? The answer is a resounding no.
From Gupta (1980)
This article starts from the premise that while economic categories - the extent of commodity production, wage labour, monetarisation of the economy, etc - should be the basis for any analysis of the production relations of pre-British India, it is the nature of class struggles arising out of particular class alignments that finally gives the decisive twist to social change. Arguing on this premise, and analysing the available evidence, this article concludes that there was little potential for industrial revolution before the British arrived in India because, whatever might have been the character of economic categories of that period, the class relations had not sufficiently matured to develop productive forces and the required class struggle for a 'revolution' to take place.
A view echoed in Raychaudhuri (1983)
Yet all of this did not amount to an economic situation comparable to that of western Europe on the eve of the industrial revolution. Her technology - in agriculture as well as manufacturers - had by and large been stagnant for centuries. [...] The weakness of the Indian economy in the mid-eighteenth century, as compared to pre-industrial Europe was not simply a matter of technology and commercial and industrial organization. No scientific or geographical revolution formed part of the eighteenth-century Indian's historical experience. [...] Spontaneous movement towards industrialisation is unlikely in such a situation.
So now we've established India did not have industrial potential, was India similar to Japan just before the Meiji era? The answer, yet again, unsurprisingly, is no. Japan's economic situation was not comparable to India's, which allowed for Japan to finance its revolution. From Yasuba (1986)
All in all, the Japanese standard of living may not have been much below the English standard of living before industrialization, and both of them may have been considerably higher than the Indian standard of living. We can no longer say that Japan started from a pathetically low economic level and achieved a rapid or even "miraculous" economic growth. Japan's per capita income was almost as high as in Western Europe before industrialization, and it was possible for Japan to produce surplus in the Meiji Period to finance private and public capital formation.
The circumstances that led to Meiji Japan were extremely unique. See Tomlinson (1985)
Most modern comparisons between India and Japan, written by either Indianists or Japanese specialists, stress instead that industrial growth in Meiji Japan was the product of unique features that were not reproducible elsewhere. [...] it is undoubtably true that Japan's progress to industrialization has been unique and unrepeatable
So there you have it. Unsubstantiated statistical assumptions, calling any number you can a drain & assuming a counterfactual for no good reason gets you this $45 trillion number. Hopefully that's enough to bury it in the ground. 1. Several authors have affirmed that Indian identity is a colonial artefact. For example see Rajan 1969:
Perhaps the single greatest and most enduring impact of British rule over India is that it created an Indian nation, in the modern political sense. After centuries of rule by different dynasties overparts of the Indian sub-continent, and after about 100 years of British rule, Indians ceased to be merely Bengalis, Maharashtrians,or Tamils, linguistically and culturally. or see Bryant 2000:
But then, it would be anachronistic to condemn eighteenth-century Indians, who served the British, as collaborators, when the notion of 'democratic' nationalism or of an Indian 'nation' did not then exist. [...] Indians who fought for them, differed from the Europeans in having a primary attachment to a non-belligerent religion, family and local chief, which was stronger than any identity they might have with a more remote prince or 'nation'.
Chakrabarti, Shubra & Patnaik, Utsa (2018). Agrarian and other histories: Essays for Binay Bhushan Chaudhuri
. Colombia University Press
Hickel, Jason (2018). How the British stole $45 trillion from India
. The Guardian
Bhuyan, Aroonim & Sharma, Krishan (2019). The Great Loot: How the British stole $45 trillion from India.
Monbiot, George (2020). English Landowners have stolen our rights. It is time to reclaim them.
Tsjeng, Zing (2020). How Britain Stole $45 trillion from India with trains | Empires of Dirt.
Chaudhury, Dipanjan (2019). British looted $45 trillion from India in today’s value: Jaishankar.
The Economic Times
Roy, Tirthankar (2019). How British rule changed India's economy: The Paradox of the Raj.
Patnaik, Utsa (2018). How the British impoverished India.
Tuovila, Alicia (2019). Expenditure method.
Dewey, Clive (2019). Changing the guard: The dissolution of the nationalist–Marxist orthodoxy in the agrarian and agricultural history of India.
The Indian Economic & Social History Review
Chandra, Bipan et al. (1989). India's Struggle for Independence, 1857-1947.
Frankema, Ewout & Booth, Anne (2019). Fiscal Capacity and the Colonial State in Asia and Africa, c. 1850-1960.
Cambridge University Press
Dalal, Sucheta (2019). IL&FS Controversy: Centre is Paying Up on Sovereign Guarantees to ADB, KfW for Group's Loan.
Chaudhuri, K.N. (1983). X - Foreign Trade and Balance of Payments (1757–1947).
Cambridge University Press
Sunderland, David (2013). Financing the Raj: The City of London and Colonial India, 1858-1940.
Dewey, Clive (1978). Patwari and Chaukidar: Subordinate officials and the reliability of India’s agricultural statistics.
Smith, Lisa (2015). The great Indian calorie debate: Explaining rising undernourishment during India’s rapid economic growth.
Duh, Josephine & Spears, Dean (2016). Health and Hunger: Disease, Energy Needs, and the Indian Calorie Consumption Puzzle.
The Economic Journal
Vankatesh, P. et al. (2016). Relationship between Food Production and Consumption Diversity in India – Empirical Evidences from Cross Section Analysis.
Agricultural Economics Research Review
Gupta, Shaibal (1980). Potential of Industrial Revolution in Pre-British India.
Economic and Political Weekly
Raychaudhuri, Tapan (1983). I - The mid-eighteenth-century background.
Cambridge University Press
Yasuba, Yasukichi (1986). Standard of Living in Japan Before Industrialization: From what Level did Japan Begin? A Comment.
The Journal of Economic History
Tomblinson, B.R. (1985). Writing History Sideways: Lessons for Indian Economic Historians from Meiji Japan
. Cambridge University Press
Rajan, M.S. (1969). The Impact of British Rule in India.
Journal of Contemporary History
Bryant, G.J. (2000). Indigenous Mercenaries in the Service of European Imperialists: The Case of the Sepoys in the Early British Indian Army, 1750-1800.
War in History
Global Millionaires Club submitted by
Binary options trading technique announced the provision of their new binary selections buying and selling software with superior quality training content material to know buying and selling beginning nineteenth January 2016. Much more specifics of Global Millionaires Club Software program are available throughout this review.
Global Millionaires Club Overview By Alexander Wilson is International Millionaires Club Program Rip-off Or Legit? Is Global Millionaires Club Software package Genuine? Browse My Global Millionaires Club Reviews Right up until believe to speculate in GlobalMillionaireClub.co APP Software package.
Description:................................. Global Millionaires Club software Product Title:............................... Global Millionaires Club Global Millionaires Club CEO:.......... Alexander Wilson Official Web page:......................... GlobalMillionaireClub.co
Global Millionaires Club Rate:.......... Cost-free
Global Millionaires Club - Overview
Binary Options Investing with Global Millionaires Club Binary Solutions Software program have very long been a superb technique to earning cash on the web and make an ideal income. Millions of binary possibilities allow traders around the world intention to go down this path to make a substantial number of profits. Nevertheless, they come across a variety of hurdles that go away them gasping for air inside an entire world that is ruthless. Alexander Wilson have come up with a Binary Selections Trading Technique termed “International Millionaires Club”, and that is designed to make binary alternatives that a lot easier to be successful with. They've got cracked the Binary Solutions Trading Application Top secret code, but does International Millionaires Club Stay up into the promise? This World-wide Millionaires Club Evaluate will consider a glance at the pluses and minuses of Global Millionaires Club to find out whether it lives up on the hoopla.
What is a Global Millionaires Club?
Permit’s begin by attempting to grasp what World Millionaires Club Application is before taking a look at the pluses and minuses. World-wide Millionaires Club is usually a binary choices computer software merchandise established by Alexander Wilson to exploit the Binary
Choices Buying and selling With binary possibilities process in put for the time being. They have found a loophole that lowers your challenges and improves your benefits. Alexander Wilson provide you with International Millionaires Club Program to take advantage of the GMC process and cut down Those people risks considerably. GlobalMillionaireClub.co computer software is trades to suit your needs immediately after specifics of your spending plan has been inserted.
Global Millionaires Club - Pros
What are the pros with this particular World-wide Millionaires Club technique? To start, it really works and that's what issues. If an item doesn’t do what it can be indicating, It is far from worth your time. Simple as that.
Global Millionaires Club is a fantastic Binary Choices Trading APP because it has the capacity to offer outcomes and I have found it to be tremendously useful. Following utilizing it for a month or so, I have created a substantial amount of revenue that may if not not here are actually probable. The 24 hour guidance is splendid. It can be a kind of professionals that basically will get disregarded but shouldn't. The Global Millionaires Club support is amazing whenever you Have got a dilemma to check with. I've experienced several hurdles to cross and their assistance team has always been there to aid me.
Global Millionaires Club - Negatives
Are there any Downsides with this particular Worldwide Millionaires Club Software program product? Yes, it is actually in close proximity to extremely hard to seek out a product that does not have cons. The only real con using this solution will be you won’t be getting a hundred% accomplishment. It is just not possible to win each individual solution and that is the way in which it is.
You can however must sit down and analyze your choices every now and then prior to moving ahead to have the type of World Millionaires Club effects you might be craving. This can be a insignificant challenge and only necessary If you would like a hundred% benefits.
Global Millionaires Club - Concluding Opinion
is so simple as it will get and anyone can utilize it. These sort of goods are scarce and to own it launched now is sort of wonderful. I'd unquestionably advocate International Millionaires Club for people people who want to make money now and make loads of it.
Is Global Millionaires Club worthwhile? Indeed, I have already been making use of International Millionaires Club for more than per month and it does the trick. The Global Millionaires Club software is simple to operate And that i are not able to imagine investing dollars without having it.
How to sign up for the Global Millionaires Club Software, Totally free + Cash Bonuses Now
- CTRL+SHIFT+DEL Clear your COOKIES so your clogged up browser does not corrupt the registration process. (Note: This is a very important registration step. Do this now, before proceeding!)
- Watch the GlobalMillionaireClub.co video.
- Enter email address.
- In the members page, choose a password. Click Register.
- Fund your account.
- With the funds added you will be able to start using the software right away.
- Enjoy the software and watch the money roll in
Global Millionaires Club Trading, Global Millionaires Club Website, GlobalMillionaireClub, GlobalMillionaireClub Review, GlobalMillionaireClub Scam, GlobalMillionaireClub.co, GlobalMillionaireClub.co APP, GlobalMillionaireClub.co Review, GlobalMillionaireClub.co Scam, Is Global Millionaires Club A Scam, Review Of Global Millionaires Club, Review Of Global Millionaires Club APP, Review Of Global Millionaires Club Binary Options, Review Of Global Millionaires Club Software, Review Of Global Millionaires Club System, UK Millionaires Club, UK Millionaires Club Review, UK Millionaires Club Scam, Global Millionaires Club APP Reviews, Global Millionaires Club Binary, Global Millionaires Club Binary Options, Global Millionaires Club Binary System, Global Millionaires Club Bonus, Global Millionaires Club Broker, Global Millionaires Club Complaints, Global Millionaires Club Download, Global Millionaires Club Free, Global Millionaires Club Login, Global Millionaires Club Review, Global Millionaires Club Reviews, Global Millionaires Club Robot, Global Millionaires Club Scam, Global Millionaires Club Software, Global Millionaires Club Software Review, Global Millionaires Club System, Global Millionaires Club System Reviews, Global Millionaires Club Testimonials,Binary Options, Binary Options Strategy, Binary Options Trading, Binary Options Trading Signals, Alexander Wilson, Alexander Wilson Global Millionaires Club, Alexander Wilson Global Millionaires Club Software, Alexander Wilson Global Millionaires Club System, Does Global Millionaires Club Software Works, Download Global Millionaires Club, Global Millionaire Club, Global Millionaire Club Review, Global Millionaire Club Scam, Global Millionaire Club Software, Global Millionaire Club System, Global Millionaires Club, Global Millionaires Club APP, Global Millionaires Club app, Global Millionaires Club information, Global Millionaires Club url, Global Millionaires Club website, Global Millionaires Club youtube video, Global Millionaires Club trading software, get Global Millionaires Club , article about Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club computer program, Global Millionaires Club the truth, Global Millionaires Club support, Global Millionaires Club support email address, Global Millionaires Club help desk, similar than Global Millionaires Club , better than Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club contact, Global Millionaires Club demo, Global Millionaires Club video tutorial, how does Global Millionaires Club work, is Global Millionaires Club the best online is Global Millionaires Club a scam, does Global Millionaires Club really work, does Global Millionaires Club actually work, Global Millionaires Club members area, Global Millionaires Club login page, Global Millionaires Club verification, Global Millionaires Club software reviews, Global Millionaires Club no fake review, Global Millionaires Club Live Broadcast, is Global Millionaires Club real, Global Millionaires Club forex trading, Global Millionaires Club binary options trading, Global Millionaires Club automated app, the Global Millionaires Club review, Global Millionaires Club signals, Global Millionaires Club mac os x, Global Millionaires Club broker sign up, Global Millionaires Club free download, reviews of Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club live results, Global Millionaires Club bonus, Global Millionaires Club honest review, Global Millionaires Club 2016, is Global Millionaires Club worth the risk, Global Millionaires Club pc desktop, Global Millionaires Club free trial,Global Millionaires Club testimonial, Global Millionaires Club scam watch dog, Global Millionaires Club warrior forum, Global Millionaires Club web version, Global Millionaires Club open a account, Global Millionaires Club laptop, Global Millionaires Club revised Method 2016, Global Millionaires Club .org, Global Millionaires Club .org review, Global Millionaires Club .org reviews, Global Millionaires Club Unbiased review, is Global Millionaires Club all hype?, real people invested in Global Millionaires Club , is Global Millionaires Club a shame, Global Millionaires Club discount, Global Millionaires Club binary option watch dog review, Global Millionaires Club youtube, seriously will Global Millionaires Club work, Global Millionaires Club facebook, Global Millionaires Club activation code, Global Millionaires Club 2016 Working, Global Millionaires Club twitter, Global Millionaires Club currency trading, Global Millionaires Club real person review, Global Millionaires Club example trade, will Global Millionaires Club work on mobile phone, Completely New Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club customer service, new Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club webinar, Global Millionaires Club webinar replay, Global Millionaires Club anybody using this, Global Millionaires Club real or fake, is Global Millionaires Club live trades real, Global Millionaires Club is this a scam, is Global Millionaires Club reliable?, Global Millionaires Club honest reviews, Global Millionaires Club is it a scam, Global Millionaires Club download software, Global Millionaires Club app review, Global Millionaires Club software download, Global Millionaires Club forum, Global Millionaires Club signals, Global Millionaires Club download page, Global Millionaires Club software demo somebody using it, Global Millionaires Club binary software, Global Millionaires Club binary options review, Global Millionaires Club members, Global Millionaires Club scam or legit,Global Millionaires Club comments, minimum deposit for Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club reviews, Global Millionaires Club binary today, Global Millionaires Club pro review, Global Millionaires Club windows 7, Global Millionaires Club windows 8 and windows XP, Global Millionaires Club scam or real, Global Millionaires Club login, Global Millionaires Club has anybody out there made any money out of it?, Global Millionaires Club vip membership pass, does Global Millionaires Club work on autopilot?, Global Millionaires Club price, is Global Millionaires Club a scam or not, will Global Millionaires Club help me, real truth about Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club System, Global Millionaires Club inside members page, Global Millionaires Club software downloads, how to download Global Millionaires Club , how to access Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club Robot, how to use Global Millionaires Club , how to trade with Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club NEWS Update and details, Global Millionaires Club sign in, the Global Millionaires Club trading options, Global Millionaires Club info, Global Millionaires Club information, Global Millionaires Club searching for new winning trades, Global Millionaires Club today, Global Millionaires Club feedback, Global Millionaires Club real user review, Global Millionaires Club customer reviews, Global Millionaires Club consumer review, Global Millionaires Club Review 2016, insider john Global Millionaires Club review, Global Millionaires Club By Anthony And Ronald review, Global Millionaires Club Anthony Ronald reviews, george s Global Millionaires Club review, Global Millionaires Club doesn't work, is Global Millionaires Club another scam or legit, Global Millionaires Club refund, Activate Global Millionaires Club , review of Global Millionaires Club , log on to Global Millionaires Club , is Global Millionaires Club manual binary trading, Global Millionaires Club bot review, Global Millionaires Club test, Global Millionaires Club explanation, what brokers work with Global Millionaires Club software, what is Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club news, new version of Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club fan Page, Global Millionaires Club breaking news, Global Millionaires Club Register, Global Millionaires Club sign up, Global Millionaires Club broker sign up, Global Millionaires Club real proof, how to activate auto trading on Global Millionaires Club ,Global Millionaires Club robot, GPS forex robot 2, Global Millionaires Club members area, Global Millionaires Club sign in, web version Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club App By Anthony And Ronald review, Global Millionaires Club Anthony And Ronald reviews, should i use Global Millionaires Club , Forex Systems Video reviews, Global Millionaires Club yes or no, do i need trading experience, Global Millionaires Club create account, Global Millionaires Club instructions, how to get a Global Millionaires Club demo, Global Millionaires Club special, desktop Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club Secret method, Join Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club ea trading app, Global Millionaires Club limited time, Global Millionaires Club pros and cons, Global Millionaires Club bad reviews, is Global Millionaires Club software automatic binary trading, Global Millionaires Club negative and positive review, Global Millionaires Club Author, Global Millionaires Club creator, who made Global Millionaires Club , what is the Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club real review, Global Millionaires Club broker, Global Millionaires Club sign up broker, Global Millionaires Club sign up broker review, Global Millionaires Club fund broker, Global Millionaires Club how to fund broker,Global Millionaires Club deposit funds into broker, how does Global Millionaires Club trade, Global Millionaires Club trading bot, what is Global Millionaires Club and cost?, Global Millionaires Club strategy, Global Millionaires Club password reset, Global Millionaires Club beta tester, Global Millionaires Club comparison, Global Millionaires Club questions and answers, rate & review Global Millionaires Club , rate and reviews Global Millionaires Club , is Global Millionaires Club site legit?, Global Millionaires Club reviews online, is Global Millionaires Club for real, Global Millionaires Club login page, Global Millionaires Club results, Global Millionaires Club winning and losing trades, Global Millionaires Club overview, Global Millionaires Club training, how to setup Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club home, real testimonial on Global Millionaires Club system, Global Millionaires Club real time trading, start trading with Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club proof, Global Millionaires Club the truth, Get Global Millionaires Club , Global Millionaires Club Review,Michael Freeman, Binaryoptionswatchdog, binaryoptionswatchdog.com, binaryoptionschannel.com, binaryoptionschannel, signals facebook group
GPS Forex Robot 3 allows you to enter trades with total and overall self confidence . So, Now you can start making these consistent profits as soon as you can sign up to become a member of this team. Advantages. Fantastic Buyer Service GPS Forex Robot 3 Strategy; The GPS Forex Robot 3 is supported by a fantastic customer support and help group ... GPS Forex Robot is one of the few legitimate trading robots that help you automate your Forex trading and still make a profit. Mark Larsen have spent years in developing one of the Best Forex Trading Systems in the domain to assure your success. It is named GPS Forex Robot. The latest version is GPS Forex Robot 3, and it makes over 30% monthly in profits, see here. Please Note: GPS Forex Robot ... However, GPS FOREX ROBOT is now profitable even in over 200 lot sizes. Profit Rate with GPS FOREX ROBOT. Although all public accounts draw beautiful upward curves, profit rate is low. The monthly profit rates on accounts other than the 250USD deposit amount have recently been less than 1%. Besides, GPS Forex Robot can also significantly enhance the success rates of making money for well advanced Forex traders. The team give these claims that the EA is right 98% of the time and in the remaining 2% when it is wrong, that Antony and Ronald have added a great reverse strategy inside which instantly opens a trade in the opposite direction and covers the small loss. View the Best Forex EA’s, the reviews and proven results and… Read more. Forex Flex EA Review. Forex Flex EA Price: $330 (Discounted Price for 1 REAL & UNLIMITED DEMO ACCOUNTS, FREE UPDATES & SUPPORT) Currency pairs: Any (EURUSD, GBPUSD, GBPCHF, AUDUSD, NZDUSD, USDCAD, USDCHF and USDJPY are tested) Timeframe: Any. Note: STRIC… Read more. Happy Frequency EA Review. Happy Frequency EA ... After doing some research, we found out that a lot of traders are reporting GPS Forex Robot and writting bad reviews about it. It seems like they are not happy about it and they warn others not to trade with them. It’s always important to know what other traders are thinking about a software before using it and we can say that they are not ... GPS Forex Robot 3 is one of the best automated forex trading software for the MetaTrader platform. They do not just make empty promises, they also have verified proof and various third party client reviews to back it up. Read this 2020 updated review of GPS Forex Robot to know what experts think about it. A forex robot is a software that is granted access to investors’ accounts to determine ...
GPS Forex Check out GPS Forex Robot: https://bit.ly/34FPGVb Follow GPS Forex Robot results: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/Fore... GPS Forex Robot Review 2020. (For version 3) This is my honest review including verified trading history. To buy this bot and get the free bonuses use this l... Let's take a look at GPS forex robot, a popular and relatively inexpensive EA for trading 4 forex pairs. If you need a broker as a U.S. resident here is one ... https://emmanueladegbola.com/gps-forex-robot-review/ In this video you would discover more information about GPS Forex Robot, most Frequently Asked Questions... (For more info visit http://empire101.gpsrobot.a.clickbetter.com/) Welcome to the gps forex robot final review. I'm happy to say we were able to finish stron...